I tried Newcastle's newest pizza spot - and it's raising the bar slice by slice

We tried out Rudy’s Pizza Napolitana in Newcastle - and it’s fair to say we loved every bite.

Pizza is just pizza, right? Bit sauce, some cheese on some dough.

Well, maybe, if your only dalliance with the Neapolitan delight is via the frozen aisle in the supermarket or see Dominoes as a culinary delight.

Nah, pizza is a whole lot more than that. It’s a social feast, full of heart and heritage. Done well it’s simplicity can be it’s real joy. It’s a vehicle of flavour, one to be enjoyed hot, cold, morning, noon and night.

I’ve got to say, though, I’m yet to really experience much of that in our great city. Newcastle doesn’t seem to do the proper Italian, not the chain or old school cheap and cheerful, all that well.

And when I heard there was to be a new kid on the block on the rather underwhelming scene, it certainly piqued my interest.

We tried out Rudy's on Grey Street in Newcastle.placeholder image
We tried out Rudy's on Grey Street in Newcastle. | NewcastleWorld

Pizza rivalries

Right, if you’re going to make a play, do it right where Rudy’s has landed. On Grey’s Street, on the Vineyard and Barluga side, they’ve positioned themselves looking directly at the famous old thoroughfare’s other doughy offering, Pizza Punks.

And, having been disappointed by my recent visit there, Rudy’s didn’t have that much to beat. But it didn’t just surpass it, it blew the socks off the place.

Walking in felt like entering a rustic pizzeria, combined with a New York loft kind-of feel. It was simple, with plenty of Italian-inspired art and raw materials decor. We were greeted at the door with a smile and bustling restaurant which has been full since the day it opened its doors at Christmas.

And it’s easy to see why, with a quirky drinks menu and lots of unique takes on some classic pizzas, accompanied by some simple sides, sauces and starters.

While you can load up on meat boards and cheese for the opening stanza, myself and my fellow diner went for a light bite, just some olives and salted crisps to whet the appetite for what was to come.

The main event

I’m a basic guy when it comes to my pizza order, I like meat and a bit of spice, if possible. So the Triple Pepperoni hit all the right notes for me with its Napoli, British + Calabrian pepperoni, stracciatella and chilli honey.

We also got the Romagnola, which consists of Emilia-Romagna aged prosciutto, rocket, topped with Grana Padano shavings.

All of that was washed down with plenty of various beers, some local, some Italian classics and for myself, my fav, an amaretto sour. This was to die for, by the way.

All I can say about the pizzas is, they were so beautifully fresh and while simple can sometimes be all you need, they had a complexity of texture and flavour that really impressed. The different variants of pepperoni made for waves of meaty flavour while the rich burrata heart was cut through by the hot honey, which maybe made my pizza a touch wet, but I loved it all the same.

The other offering was divine, with the salty ham and cheese balanced with greenery on the tastiest of tasty doughs, with just the right amount of fire around the edges.

To finish

While my rather full fellow diner could do little but stomach a refreshingly creamy vanilla gelato, I went for the classic of all classics - the tiramisu. I do see myself as a bit of a connoisseur in this field, and often at these kind of places the dessert can be an afterthought, but not here. This was just the perfect flourish to a meal that had everything we could have wanted, for a damp Wednesday night in February.

The type of place to go any night, any day. For a relaxed date, or a work meet, or a catch up with friends it was perfect. Great vibe, good decor, top service and even better food. Would definitely recommend.

Raising the bar of Italian eateries in the city, slice by slice.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice