Ex-magistrate fell asleep at the wheel and caused horror crash that left woman with life changing injuries


A former magistrate who fell asleep at the wheel and caused a horror crash that left a woman with life changing injuries has kept her freedom.
Jacquelin Curtis, who sat in English law courts for 15 years until she moved to Scotland, and her retired police officer husband had taken turns driving during a 10-hour, 400 mile overnight journey before the catastrophic collision.
The head-on smash in Northumberland left support worker Susan Richards with a small subarachnoid haemorrhage, multiple fractures and in need of emergency surgery. Miss Richards said in an impact statement she was unable to return to work, can no longer enjoy simple things like long dog walks and her general quality of life has been reduced.
She added that she is overwhelmed with anger, deeply distressed and said: "I am not the person I was before this happened." Newcastle Crown Court heard Curtis, who owns a pre-school nursery in Kent, had left Sittingbourne with her husband and their small dog at around 9pm to avoid traffic and hot weather during the trip home to Galashiels.
Her husband had been driving at the start of the journey but she was behind the wheel for the last stretch, from Washington services and the collision happened on the A696 in Northumberland. Curtis, of Abbotsford Road, Galashiels, Scotland, also suffered serious injuries and multiple fractures, including to her spinal vertebrae, herself in the crash.
The 62-year-old, who has a clean driving licence, character references and no convictions, denied causing serious injury by dangerous driving and claimed she was well rested and alert before the crash but was found guilty by a jury after a trial in November. Curtis, who was familiar with the long journey, denied falling asleep while driving.
NewcastleWorld: Essential is our weekly newsletter rounding up the city’s best headlines every Thursday - sign up for free
Judge Tom Moran today sentenced her to two years, suspended for two years, with 200 hours unpaid work, a four year ban with extended test requirement and £4,000 costs.
The judge told her: "I don't consider that you deliberately lied or misled the jury in the evidence you gave. I have formed the view you don't really know what happened, you just find it very hard to accept you must have fallen asleep."


Judge Moran said Curtis had taken positive steps during the long journey to prevent fatigue, including regular stops and switching drivers and told her: "I accept you genuinely thought you were adequately rested. Obviously you were wrong."
The judge said Curtis's former position as a magistrate has "no bearing" on the sentence imposed. Curtis handed in character references, has never been in trouble before, has a exemplary driving record and has been "upset and remorseful" over what happened.
Rhys Rosser, defending, said Curtis spent a long time in hospital and the crash has had a long term impact on her mentally and physically. Prosecutor Jane Foley told the court during the trial the case was a "tragedy" for all involved and added it was "caused by the defendant falling asleep, albeit briefly".
Miss Foley said: "This case concerns a head-on road traffic collision on the A696 in Northumberland which left a woman Susan Richards with multiple serious, life changing injuries. The Crown say that collision was caused by dangerous driving on the part of the defendant Jacquelin Curtis who drove her grey Ford Galaxy onto the wrong side of the road and into the path of the Vauxhall."
The court heard the victim was driving lawfully on the eastbound single carriageway and Curtis was driving west. Miss Foley said: "The Crown say the defendant misjudged a bend and her Ford motor car crossed into the oncoming lane, directly into the path of the Vauxhall. The two vehicles collided offside to offside, essentially head-on."
Miss Foley added: "The Crown's case is a straight forward but catastrophic case of wrong-side driving." Miss Richards suffered a small subarachnoid haemorrhage, a brain bleed, a fractured spine, fractured sternum and a fracture and dislocation to her right foot that required emergency surgery.