Decision on St James' Park STACK fanzone as rival Newcastle bars take legal fight to High Court
An alliance of Newcastle bars and pubs has lost a legal challenge against the STACK fanzone outside St James’ Park.
After the popular venue was granted a five-year extension to its planning permission by Newcastle City Council earlier this year, the NE1 Hospitality Group sought to have that overturned in the High Court.
Rival operators have argued that the success of the STACK was taking away vital trade from others and alleged that the decision to allow it to stay open until 2031 was “unlawful”.


But a judge has now ruled in the council’s favour and dismissed the application for a judicial review.
In his ruling, High Court Judge Klein said that there was “no arguable ground for judicial review which has a realistic prospect of success”.
He found that if a claim was to be made by the objectors, it should have been in response to the original decision to grant planning permission for the St James’ Park STACK in October 2023 – rather than against the extension.
Meanwhile, another new STACK opened in the city centre just last week at Worswick Chambers on Pilgrim Street.
The judge also ordered that the claimants must pay the council £17,145 in legal costs.
A council spokesperson said: “We welcome the Court’s decision, which upholds the Local Planning Authority’s assessment and determination of this application.
“We acknowledge the ongoing challenges faced by the hospitality industry and remain committed to supporting both established businesses and new operators in the city.
“We understand that recent years have been difficult for businesses, but Newcastle is a vibrant city, and we continue to work to grow and diversify the sector.
“We are proud of the famous hospitality offer here in Newcastle, it encapsulates the warm and welcoming reputation of the Geordie people. We are committed to working with businesses across the city to ensure that our hospitality offer continues to thrive.”
Planning permission was first granted to the operators of STACK in October 2023.
The NE1 Hospitality Group, which has recently been critical of the impact of Newcastle’s Christmas markets on existing city businesses, had warned in August that jobs were at “serious risk” because of the STACK being such a draw for patrons throughout the week – and not just on Newcastle United matchdays.
A number of well-known Tyneside bars, pubs, and restaurants have closed their doors this year as the hospitality industry struggles to cope with rising costs, including the likes of Prohibition, Horticulture, and the Earl of Pitt Street.
A spokesperson for the NE1 Hospitality Group, which represents more than 100 venues, said on Monday: “It is really frustrating but on we go and we continue to want to work alongside the council. When you look at the rates increases, wage increases, and all the other pressures on us, I would hope that the council would reach out, but they remain embarrassingly silent.”
