'Eye-wateringly expensive' - Staffing shortage and poor council homes costing Newcastle taxpayers £100,000s

A severe staffing shortage and the poor state of council homes is costing Newcastle taxpayers hundreds of thousands of pounds in legal fees.

Newcastle City Council bosses have revealed that a dramatic jump in claims over dilapidated housing and the authority’s inability to recruit solicitors has led to “eye-watering” costs to hire outside legal support. The council’s legal department is expected to overrun its budget by almost £800,000 this year, according to a report presented to politicians on Tuesday.

placeholder image
LDRS

That overspend is partly blamed on a “significant” rise in claims related to disrepair in council housing, which have risen from around 50 per year to as many as 80 in a single month, coinciding with a “severe problem” with recruitment.

The council took back control of around 25,000 properties from management organisation Your Homes Newcastle last year and has since been ordered by regulators to deal with “serious failings” in that housing stock – including damp and mould problems.

Lib Dem councillor Gareth Kane said at a finance scrutiny panel on Tuesday that the spike in  housing-related legal claims was “quite shocking”, while Labour’s Joyce McCarty added that politicians were “very concerned” about the mounting costs of agency staff.

Matt Wilton, the council’s deputy chief executive, told councillors that the lack of capacity within the authority’s legal department to deal with the growing number and complexity of claims was forcing bosses to seek help from agencies or law firms at “eye-wateringly expensive” prices.

He added that housing chiefs being “proactive”, having promised to visit all tenants and conduct a detailed survey of the condition of its homes, was pushing some problems to the fore but that would be better in the long run.

A budget report from Mr Wilton confirmed that spending on the council’s legal services department is expected to total almost £2.5 million this year, compared to a budgeted £1.7 million.

placeholder image
LDRS

Explaining the projected £773,000 overspend, it adds: “There has been for some time a steady increase in the volume of legal work that the department is required to undertake. This has particularly impacted teams supporting statutorily required services such as Adult Social Care, Children’s Social Care and Housing and Litigation. 

“The Council has also seen a significant rise over several years in housing disrepair claims from approximately 50 per year to, in some instances 50 to 80 in a single month. At the same time as volume increasing the nature and complexity of work in some areas has meant more time and resource is required to properly protect the Council and support frontline services delivering statutory services for residents. 

“In terms of the impact on budget for the department a further issue we have had for some time, but which is increasingly having a direct impact, is in terms of retention and recruitment of staff. Whilst all councils face challenges in terms of legal recruitment this is currently a severe problem within Newcastle.

“The recent external review undertaken by Lawyers in Local Government confirmed that out of the other LA7 authorities one pays solicitors three scale points more, two pay two scale points more and two have graded solicitor posts at a higher level, delivering improved remuneration without the requirement for management responsibilities. 

“Consequently, our recruitment campaigns have typically resulted in little or in some cases no applicants meaning there is an inability to recruit leading to the need to secure locum solicitors and legal officers for work that must be undertaken. Unfortunately, the locum market is highly competitive and rates payable for such cover far exceeds that of internal delivery.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice