Stack fanzone at Newcastle's St James’ Park hit by legal challenge as bars revolt – what it means

It has proved a big hit with patrons since opening in 2024, but the Stack fanzone outside St James’ Park has become a source of major concern for rival bars and pubs in Newcastle city centre.

News broke on Tuesday that an alliance of more than 100 venues was launching a legal challenge against Newcastle City Council’s decision to extend the Stack’s planning permission to 2031.

The newly-formed NE1 Hospitality Group claims that the move was “unlawful” and has complained that the emergence of the 2,000-capacity site next to the home of Newcastle United has damaged other businesses that have been long-standing fixtures in the city’s famous nightlife.

St James' Park Stack fanzoneplaceholder image
St James' Park Stack fanzone | LDRS

An application has been made for a judicial review that, if successful, could result in the council’s decision being quashed.

Here is what you need to know about the dispute and what comes next.

What is St James’ Stack?

Constructed from 56 repurposed shipping containers, St James’ Stack is located on Gallowgate next to the football stadium. The fanzone and leisure hub is home to bars and street food vendors, has hosted more than 1,400 stage performances, and now employs 175 people.

An earlier Stack development previously operated on Pilgrim Street in Newcastle city centre, before closing down to make way for the new HMRC offices being built there, while another is due to open at nearby Worswick Chambers.

Set up in partnership with Newcastle United FC and its shirt sponsor Sela, the St James’ version of the project opened in summer 2024.

What decision did Newcastle City Council make on it?

The council’s planning committee originally granted planning permission to Newcastle United Football Club Projects Limited for the development in October 2023, for a temporary period of three years. Earlier this summer, an extension to that permission was also granted, meaning that the approval now runs until September 2031.

In a report assessing the extension application, city planners concluded that the Stack would “continue to add to the overall vibrancy of this part of the urban core of the city” and was considered to “broaden the leisure offer in the city centre”.

Why is it controversial?

The development of St James’ Stack sparked opposition from other venues in the city centre a couple of years ago. In September 2023, 59 businesses wrote to the council’s planning committee to warn that the fanzone risked “extremely negative impacts” by driving customers away from other bars and pubs reliant on matchday trade when NUFC are playing at home.

This week, the new NE1 Hospitality Group announced that it had now applied for a judicial review of the council’s decision to grant the five-year extension.

They have complained that Stack operates every day of the week, not simply as a matchday fanzone, and “threatens the future of Newcastle’s traditional hospitality scene”.

Numerous leisure operators claimed that they were experiencing a drop in trade as a result of the Stack operation, at a time when hospitality venues are already struggling to deal with increases to employers’ national insurance contributions and other cost pressures.

The group said: “This isn’t about growth — it’s about displacement. The Fanzone is drawing trade away from the very venues that helped build Newcastle’s reputation for hospitality. We’re not against progress but it must be fair and sustainable.”

What is the NE1 Hospitality Group?

The group describes itself as an alliance representing more than 100 Newcastle bars and pubs. It is chaired by Tom Byron, of the Dog and Parrot on Clayton Street West, and also counts some of Tyneside’s best-known leisure operators among its membership – including the Vaulkhard Group and Ladhar Group.

What is a judicial review and what happens next?

A judicial review is a means of challenging a planning decision in the High Court, but there are only certain circumstances under which one can be brought.

When a council refuses planning permission for a development, the applicant has the right to appeal to the Planning Inspectorate to seek to have that overturned.

But those opposed to a planning application that is approved do not have an equivalent right of appeal, which can lead objectors to turn to the judicial review process instead.

Importantly, a judicial review cannot be brought based on the qualities of the actual development itself. Instead, it focuses on whether a planning decision was made in a proper and lawful manner – for example, if a council failed to consider relevant issues, did not abide by the correct statutory process, or acted in a demonstrably irrational way.

After an application for a judicial review is made, the court will decide whether a case is arguable and can proceed to a final hearing or will be dismissed.

If the request for a judicial review into the St James’ Stack was granted, the court could ultimately decide to quash the council’s original decision. In that case, the council would then have to retake the decision and correct any errors identified.

What are the grounds for the complaint?

In its statement released on Tuesday, the NE1 Hospitality Group said it was requesting a judicial review of the decision as it had “been advised that it is unlawful”. The full details of their legal argument have not been released as yet, though venues are known to be unhappy that the council’s five-year extension decision was made under ‘delegated powers’ by planning officers rather than being put before elected politicians on the planning committee.

An objection lodged on behalf of the group to the planning application claimed that businesses’ objections were not properly taken into account when the original 2023 decision was made. It also argued that further information, including a full impact assessment of the Stack development on leisure businesses in the city centre, was required before planning permission for the extension could be lawfully granted.

However, on Tuesday a spokesperson for the NE1 Hospitality Group said it hoped to “negotiate an outcome acceptable to all” that could avoid the judicial review going ahead.

What has the response been?

Newcastle City Council said it “cannot regulate competition in the city centre” and that would not be grounds for it to refuse a planning application, but that it understood the concerns raised and the difficulties being faced by the hospitality sector.

They added: “This is an ongoing legal process and so we cannot comment further at this time but we do want to work with businesses to ensure Newcastle continues to thrive as a hub for hospitality.”

Both Stack and Newcastle United were contacted for a response, but have not commented at this stage.

When approached for a comment, the council’s Lib Dem opposition leader Colin Ferguson called for “suitable opportunities for dialogue on the industry’s concerns” to be pursued.

He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service: “We appreciate the relationship between the council and key partners in the city centre is delicate and that stakeholders feel frustrated at difficulties in engaging with the council since the recent departure of key officers. The Lib Dem Opposition group would welcome a briefing from senior council officers on the legal and financial implications of a High Court challenge to the council’s licensing policy.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice