The likes of the mercurial Peter Beardsley, powerhouse striker Les Ferdinand and local hero Alan Shearer all became iconic figures with the Gallowgate faithful as the Magpies mixed it with the great and the good in the Premier League and abroad.
Several big-name players also made their way to Tyneside without really living up to the hype that enveloped the club when their signings were confirmed.
But there have been a number of players that have represented United with pride without ever really capturing the headlines during their time at St James Park.
Perhaps their departures made people reassess their worth and contribution to the cause, but there can be no doubt they added something to the side without overshadowing some of the more attractive names within the squad.
NewcastleWorld takes look back over the last three decades and picks out 10 of the Magpies most underrated players.
5. Danny Simpson
After helping the Magpies secure the Championship title, Simpson was a consistent presence under Chris Hughton and Alan Pardew. He played a key role in the surprise 5th place finish achieved under the latter and was unfortunate to be replaced by France international Mathieu Debuchy. Photo: Jamie McDonald
6. Kevin Gallacher
With links over a potential loan move for Brazilian superstar Ronaldo being mentioned, the arrival of Scottish international Kevin Gallacher could have been seen as underwhelming. But the former Blackburn Rovers forward became a hardworking and committed outlet for Sir Bobby Robson as he made his first moves as Magpies manager. | Getty Images
7. Antoine Sibierski
When Sibierski arrived from Man City on August deadline day in 2006, it was a bit of a mystery, however the French striker, during his one season at St James’s Park, would go down as one of the club’s best-ever free transfers. He scored three Premier League goals but was better known for UEFA Cup exploits. Photo: PAUL COOKNEY
8. Scott Sellars
Despite being overshadowed by the arrival of David Ginola in July 1995, the role Scott Sellars played in establishing United in the Premier League following promotion should not be underestimated. Had a wonderful left foot that provided assists aplenty. | Getty Images