Eddie Howe was right to drop Nick Woltemade from Newcastle United XI - on one condition

Should Newcastle United boss Eddie Howe have started Nick Woltemade and Jacob Murphy against Barcelona?

Eddie Howe’s Newcastle United displayed plenty of heart and desire but fell short on quality in their Champions League opener against Barcelona.

Newcastle Coach Eddie Howe reacts on the sidelines during the UEFA Champions League 2025/26 League Phase MD1 match between Newcastle United FC and FC Barcelona at St James' Park on September 18, 2025 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)placeholder image
Newcastle Coach Eddie Howe reacts on the sidelines during the UEFA Champions League 2025/26 League Phase MD1 match between Newcastle United FC and FC Barcelona at St James' Park on September 18, 2025 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images) | Getty Images

England international Marcus Rashford was the man to provide the final third quality with a second-half brace. The Magpies pulled a goal back late on through Anthony Gordon, but it was too little, too late.

The overriding emotion at full-time was one of pride after the Magpies went toe to toe with one of Europe’s best, though there was also a lingering feeling of what if.

And that comes from Howe’s team selection after he left £69million club-record signing Nick Woltemade and Jacob Murphy, both of whom combined for the only goal of the game in Saturday’s 1-0 win over Wolves, out of the starting line-up.

Eddie Howe explains Nick Woltemade and Jacob Murphy decision

Explaining the decision, Howe told NewcastleWorld: “I have to make decisions for the benefit of the player sometimes.

“That was a really difficult one for Nick. Any player would want to start any game but I’ve got to try and manage him into the team and try and make sure he stays fit. That was always at the heart of this decision.

“Of course, knowing we have Anthony suspended as well for the next game [versus AFC Bournemouth]. And it’s the same with Jacob, he’s nursing an Achilles problem. We just want to keep the squad fit and available for as many games as possible.”

Eddie Howe was right to drop Woltemade & Murphy - on one condition

Discussing Howe’s decision on Geordie Journos, NewcastleWorld editor Liam Kennedy felt the Newcastle head coach was wrong to name the pair on the bench, though he could understand his reasoning.

However, if the Magpies don’t get a positive result at AFC Bournemouth on Sunday, then Liam believes it’ll be all for nothing.

Liam said: “I love Eddie Howe, I love everything he's done, I don't even think I need to say that because I think that's so obvious. But I think he got it wrong today, I genuinely think he got it wrong.

“I can see the reason as to why he didn't start Woltemade and went with different players. He's so limited with his options and he's trying to balance things up with the game at the weekend and maybe a style of play today, there were lots of reasons.

“I just feel like it was almost a little bit of sabotage. I think if Woltemade plays, and possibly [Jacob] Murphy, even though I thought [Anthony] Elanga was great for the first 45 minutes, but I think if those two players play, I think Newcastle United might get a result.

“I can never fault this team for effort, for application, I mean, they do everyone proud every time they go out on that football pitch, they did it again tonight, but the lack of quality really let them down.

“It's not on Anthony Gordon but he’s just not a striker. But he [Eddie Howe] doesn't have another option, I get it, but just that is not an option either in my opinion now.

“He'll have done the right thing if they go to Bournemouth on Sunday and get a result. But I felt tonight was the occasion. The city, the football club, everything, it felt like tonight was the occasion, and I don't think Eddie Howe presented the best team he could have put out tonight.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice