I watched Newcastle United's defeat at Chelsea - and here's my honest opinion on Eddie Howe

Newcastle United suffered their third defeat of the Premier League season v Chelsea at Stamford Bridge.

This was meant to be the season of progress. It was meant to be a time free of any European burden, one that loosened the limbs and set players free to attack a Champions League charge. It’s been anything but so far.

That faltering narrative was added to at Stamford Bridge as Newcastle United again came up short against Chelsea in the Premier League.

But what did we learn, if anything, from the encounter? Here’s the NewcastleWorld, five things...

Alexander Isak and Joe Willock react after a missed opportunity during the English Premier League football match between Chelsea and Newcastle United at Stamford Bridge in London on October 27, 2024.placeholder image
Alexander Isak and Joe Willock react after a missed opportunity during the English Premier League football match between Chelsea and Newcastle United at Stamford Bridge in London on October 27, 2024. | AFP via Getty Images

ISAK!

Form is temporary, class is permanent. Well, that’s what I am sticking to.

Thing is, let’s be honest here, Isak’s form is in the bin. For whatever reason, he’s been a million miles away from the player of last season, and that’s putting it lightly.

In his defence, he’s been a lot more involved in the last two encounters, but his errors have crept up.

He may well have scored against Chelsea, but his errors led to two home goals and his inability to pass to Joelinton when he’d rounded the keeper probably cost the Magpies a draw, too.

Love Isak. Don’t love what I’m seeing from him at the moment.

Are we ready to talk about Harvey Barnes yet?

He’s scored goals, for Newcastle, of that there is no doubt but I’m yet to be totally convinced by the player, especially when he starts games.

What is certain, Barnes looks lethal when the ball is in and around the box, although he was anything but in this encounter.

It’s almost like, at times, he stunts attacks, things end when they reach him, and that’s not really the role of a winger - they’re meant to be the creative spark or end product, not the one who closes it off.

If he wants to start, he needs to do better than this, or what he’s produced this season. Considerably better.

Is Eddie Howe under pressure?

At the moment, when talking about serious pressure, I’d suggest not. But that doesn’t mean it won’t be ramping up.

Newcastle can get beat any given year at Stamford Bridge, I mean, they mostly do - it’s now 14 seasons since a win at the ground - but this loss adds to the bigger picture. And the one being painted is of a manager struggling to improve the side, struggling to take them forward and things going a little stale. That goes for off the pitch, as well as on it, that must be added.

If Newcastle crash out of the cup to a second-string Chelsea in midweek, then lose to Arsenal at the weekend, things could well be white hot by the time United go to the City Ground after the next international break.

Systemic problems run deep at Newcastle?

Eddie Howe seems married to 4-3-3. He seems unwilling to change tact. And, to me, that appears to be a real flaw in his managerial game.

Top managers set systems that suit their players best, they also find ways of answering questions posed by other teams in preparation and also, at times, in games. Howe has not done that to any real level recently, and questions must be asked.

The system doesn’t seem to suit any of his midfield three, or potential two of his back four, however he persists with no real deviation. It’s a dangerous game to play.

Change has been minimal from the team that finished fourth, a campaign in which only Aston Villa found them out. Last season, from Brighton (a), you could argue eight or nine teams worked them out. This season, it seems like all sides have found a way to combat tired-looking Newcastle.

Are defenders showing their age - or again is this a deeper issue?

In many ways, this feeds into the point above.

Fabian Schar and Dan Burn have been outstanding defenders for Newcastle United, the former, in particular. But you have to wonder, on evidence like Sunday, is their time coming?

Watching Nicolas Jackson, Cole Palmer and then Christopher Nkunku cause absolute havoc with their mix of speed, wit, guile and physicality it is easy to see why Marc Guehi was sought, a defender who is comfortable playing high, on the ball, and even when asked to chase forwards back.

Both players look like they’re really struggling at the moment. Sven Botman’s return can’t come soon enough.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice