'Unwatchable' - Italian media disagree over Sandro Tonali as Newcastle United star nets late winner

The Italian media delivered mixed reviews on Sandro Tonali’s performance against Israel.

Newcastle United star Sandro Tonali netted a stoppage-time winner as Italy came out on the right side of a nine-goal thriller in Israel.

Sandro Tonali of Italy in action challenges for the ball with Kevor Palumets of Estonia during the FIFA World Cup 2026 qualifier match between Italy and Estonia at Stadio di Bergamo on September 05, 2025 in Bergamo, Italy. (Photo by Mattia Ozbot/Getty Images)placeholder image
Sandro Tonali of Italy in action challenges for the ball with Kevor Palumets of Estonia during the FIFA World Cup 2026 qualifier match between Italy and Estonia at Stadio di Bergamo on September 05, 2025 in Bergamo, Italy. (Photo by Mattia Ozbot/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Italians twice came from behind before taking a 4-2 lead with 10 minutes left to play. But two goals in two minutes saw the hosts level. And that looked to be that, until Tonali struck in the 91st minute.

It was a huge moment as Italy aim to qualify for their first World Cup since 2014. Gennaro Gattuso’s side sit second in Group I, three points behind leaders Norway with four games remaining.

Italian media don’t agree over Sandro Tonali’s performance against Israel

Corriere dello Sport handed Tonali an 8/10, writing: “Biton was forced out by Locatelli's own goal; perhaps his slightly off-centre position didn't help him, but he had plenty of class, and it showed.

“He didn't give up, tried a shot, grew in the second half, and scored the goal that took us to second place: one of Ringhio's boys.”

However, Sky Sport Italia and Football Italia were less complimentary about his performance, giving Tonali a 6/10 and 6.5/10 rating, respectively.

“Unwatchable in the first half, but he improved significantly in the second, and his goal, even if it was a mistake by the opposing defense, was too important not to earn a good rating,” Sky wrote. “INEXHAUSTIBLE.”

Football Italia said: “Played a bit wider on the left flank in the second half. Hard to beat physically, but his passing accuracy was beyond disappointing (just 70%). Luckily, he scored the winner.”

Sandro Tonali comes through Italy duty unscathed

Tonali started both of Italy’s World Cup qualifier wins over Estonia and Israel, and Newcastle will be pleased to hear he came through unscathed.

It comes after the midfielder linked up with his national team managing a slight shoulder issue. Tonali sustained the issue against Liverpool and played through the pain barrier at Leeds United.

"I spoke with the gaffer and the doctor, it was a difficult,” Tonali said. “I worked every day for eight hours, starting early in the morning and finishing after dinner just to play in this game. The shoulder is not 100%, it was a little bit of a risk to play but the team and the game was so important.

“Every player with injuries here, if they have 1% chance to play, they play. We need to keep working and pushing because the Premier League is long. We go away for the international break and come back with 100% concentration.”

Busy period coming up for Sandro Tonali and Newcastle United

Newcastle host Wolverhampton Wanderers in the Premier League on Saturday, which marks the start of a busy period for Eddie Howe’s side leading up to the October international break.

After Wolves, Barcelona visit St James’ Park in their Champions League group phase opener before making the long trip to Bournemouth four days later. A midweek Carabao Cup tie against Bradford then follows before the Magpies end September with a home match versus Arsenal.

Howe’s side then travel to Royale Union Saint-Gilloise in the Champions League and then host Nottingham Forest before the next two-week international break.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice