Newcastle United 1-1 Manchester United: Player ratings, heroes & villains as Magpies miss out on deserved win

Newcastle United star Allan Saint-Maximin. (Photo by PAUL ELLIS/AFP via Getty Images)Newcastle United star Allan Saint-Maximin. (Photo by PAUL ELLIS/AFP via Getty Images)
Newcastle United star Allan Saint-Maximin. (Photo by PAUL ELLIS/AFP via Getty Images) | AFP via Getty Images
The heroes, villains and player ratings from Newcastle United’s 1-1 draw with Manchester United at St James’ Park.

A point apiece for Newcastle United and Manchester United - but perhaps a missed opportunity for all three by Eddie Howe’s side.

Allan Saint-Maximin’s seventh-minute opener had a sell-out St James’ Park rocking. And they had so many chances to win.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

David de Gea kept the Magpies at bay - denying Saint-Maximin from point-blank range - before substitute half-time Edinson Cavani poked home a scrappy equaliser.

The Red Devils’ goalkeeper wasn’t done there however, as Howe’s men pushed for a winner.

As Jacob Murphy’s shot cannoned off the inside of the post, Miguel Almiron picked up the loose ball and De Gea tipped the Paraguayan effort over, which has destined for the top corner.

The heroes

Joelinton: The best central midfielder in the world? Seriously though, what a performance from the Brazilian. He again ran himself into the ground but his know-how in possession was equally impressive. Rarely lost the ball. His transformation under Eddie Howe is extraordinary. Long may it continue.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Sean Longstaff: There were a few pre-match groans when Longstaff was named on the teamsheet but there can be little complaints over his performance, particularly in the first-half as he won the ball high off Raphael Varane for Saint-Maximin’s opener. Admittedly, the midfielder did tire towards the end on his first start since October 30 versus Chelsea.

Allan Saint-Maximin: So nearly the match-winner with a superb strike past David de Gea. He caused Diogo Dalot all sorts of problems down the left before becoming the central focal point of the attack after Callum Wilson’s enforced withdrawal. Really should have made it 2-0 early in the second-half, which perhaps took the shine off a really influential performance.

The villains

Cristiano Ronaldo: Jeered and booed all evening by the Newcastle fans, including the shooting drill in the warm-up. A frustrated figure throughout, as proven when he was perhaps lucky to avoid a red card for a swipe on Ryan Fraser. Fair to say he didn’t enjoy his evening on Tyneside one bit, which makes a change giving his goalscoring record against the Magpies.

David de Gea: Stopped Newcastle from getting that all-important second. Tipped a Jonjo Shelvey effort over the crossbar, kept Ryan Fraser’s near post attempt out. The best save of them all? Denying Saint-Maximin from point-blank range. Although critics will argue that the Frenchman should have scored. An unbelievable save from Almiron late on.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Edinson Cavani: The half-time substitute who denied Newcastle a deserved three points. It was a scrappy goal mind, with his initial shot from Diogo Dalot’s low delivery blocked by Jamaal Lascelles before the follow-up was poked home past the grounded Martin Dubravka.

Player ratings

Newcastle United: Dubravka 7; Krafth 7, Lascelles 6, Schar 7, Manquillo 7; Shelvey 7, Longstaff, 7 Joelinton 8; Fraser 7 (Almiron, 74: 7), Saint-Maximin 8;(Gayle, 83: N/A) Wilson 6. (Murphy, 34: 6)

Manchester United: De Gea 9, Dalot 7, Varane 7, Maguire 6, Telles 7; McTominay 6 (Matic, 80: N/A) Fred 6 (Cavani 45, 8) Fernandes 6, Greenwood 5 (Sancho, 45: 7) Rashford 7, Ronaldo 5.

Who do Newcastle play next?

Newcastle head to Goodison Park on Thursday night (December 30) for a reunion with Rafa Benitez’s Everton.

Everton’s Boxing Day match at Burnley due to injuries and positive COVID-19 cases in their first-team squad.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.