Newcastle United could unleash new-look trio vs Fulham in major £160m selection dilemma

Newcastle United travel to Fulham on Saturday - and Eddie Howe admits he is facing one his toughest selection calls to date.

Who starts in the midfield three is giving Howe a healthy problem on the back of last Sunday’s 2-1 comeback win at Wolverhampton Wanderers.

placeholder image
AFP via Getty Images

Bruno Guimaraes, Joelinton and Sean Longstaff started at Molineux, however the latter two were withdrawn at half-time and replaced by Joe Willock and Sandro Tonali.

The introduction of Willock and Tonali helped United come from 1-0 down with Fabian Schar and Harvey Barnes both scoring from outside the box. It was the first time Willock, Tonali and Guimaraes had all played in the same midfield together.

The midfield conundrum

“Is it the toughest midfield selection conundrum? Yeah, I think so,” said Howe. “But these are the decisions that we wanted when we signed those players. We felt we needed those, especially for a season in the Champions League. Then when you add Lewis Miley to that group, you’ve got six outstanding central midfield players.

“But a club like ourselves, with the ambitions that we have, we need that strength in depth, and we possibly don’t have that in other positions in the squad. So my wish is that they all stay fit, they all push each other, and I have some really tough decisions to make.”

On Willock and Tonali specifically, Howe said: “They’re certainly pushing to start. I want everyone to be pushing to start. The beauty of our recent performances is the players coming onto the pitch in whatever situation we’ve been in have impressed, and the last few team selections have been difficult because of that reason.

“I think Sandro is in a much better place than he was, the two international games will have definitely helped him and I think you saw that in his position against Wolves, he was very good. We’ve got really good competition for places in midfield at the moment.”

‘Sandro’s very keen to play’

Newcastle United midfielder Sandro Tonaliplaceholder image
Newcastle United midfielder Sandro Tonali | Carl Recine

Tonali started the Carabao Cup win at Nottingham Forest on his first game for 10 months but has had to settle for substitute appearances against Tottenham Hotspur and Wolves since.

Howe has been keen to ease the 24-year-old back in, something Italy didn’t do after he played back-to-back full matches in the space of three days against France and Israel.

“We'll always take an overview of everything and it's never as simple as maybe people say, and it's maybe not as complicated as we try and make it,” said Howe. “But I think, whenever there's a big spike in load, so whether there's a big jump in any type of physical area with the players, we have to be a little bit mindful of that and protect them.

“But Sandro's very keen to play, we're very keen to see him play but the competition for places is... In midfield, is probably as strong as I've ever had here. You've got internationals all fighting for starting spots. So, Sandy will play, he'll get his opportunities, like he did against Wolves on Sunday, and he's got to grab them with both hands."

‘A fully flying Joe Willock is a real asset’

placeholder image
Getty Images

Willock, meanwhile, is aiming to make his first Premier League start since Fulham away in April.

The former Arsenal man’s 2023-24 campaign was plagued by an Achilles injury, while he also gave everyone a scare when he picked up a thigh injury just 15 minutes into the cup tie at Forest. It came after Willock reminded everyone of his quality by scoring less than 60 seconds in.

Howe said: “I think it was really evident, his running ability, his ball-carrying ability, his creativity around the box. Slightly unpredictable, Joe, you never quite know what he's going to do, but that's a strength, not a weakness. That unpredictability is really good from an attacking perspective.

“And he's very popular with the players. They see his qualities, they know what he can bring. So, a fit and fully flying Joe Willock is a real asset for us.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice