Wow - Alan Shearer thinks Leeds United were robbed against Newcastle United

Newcastle United were awarded a late penalty for handball against Leeds United on Wednesday.

Alan Shearer believes Newcastle United were fortunate to be awarded a late penalty against Leeds United.

With the Magpies trailing, Lewis Hall’s cross was judged to have struck Brenden Aaronson’s arm in a natural position. VAR also checked whether the contact was made inside the penalty area.

Daniel Farke protested the decision in his post-match press conference - believing Leeds were hard done by. The German’s woes were compounded by Bruno Guimaraes burying the spot-kick before Harvey Barnes scored a 102nd-minute winner.

Alan Shearer agrees with Daniel Farke

Speaking on The Rest Is Football, Toon icon Shearer surprisingly agreed that there was little Aaronson could do about Hall’s cross. He said: “As you know, I always give you an honest opinion. And I was the same thing. I mean, what is he meant to do with his arms when he's going to challenge like that?

“It's just not handball. It can't be handball. I just don't agree with it. So I'm with you on that one, Micah (Richards), but obviously I'll take it.”

‘A great atmosphere’ - Alan Shearer

Shearer went on to praise Leeds for their approach despite falling agonisingly short in the 4-3 thriller. He added: “It was a great game. I was really impressed with Leeds. It was so well organised. Maybe it was their naivety or their bravery or whatever it was, but they kept on going and going.

“They pressed Newcastle, went man for man and it was just a great game to watch. I was like, ‘Oh my God, what are Newcastle doing?’ It was just one of those great games of football. Luckily for Newcastle, they were on the right end of it. It was just a pleasure to be there. It was a great atmosphere.”

Eddie Howe toasts Harvey Barnes

Eddie Howe admitted Newcastle were not at their best but was pleased to see Barnes score the crucial goals. He said: "(It is) difficult to sum up. It was one of those classic games here where I don't think we weren't our best but showed great character and the game turned our way at the end which is a rare thing for us. It's great for it to go the other way today.

“It wasn't a perfect performance, there's stuff to improve but the mentality is the key thing. If you are losing, you need that 'never say die' attitude. We were a bit flat at start of game which was surprising.

“We are disappointed with that aspect of our game but maybe conceding helped us in this game because it gave us something to chase and played with a bit more freedom. I'm delighted for Harvey to score the winning goal, a great moment for him. He has done it before for us but he deserves it."

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice