placeholder image
Getty Images

Newcastle United player ratings v Man City: 'Passive' & 'anonymous' 4/10s in 3-1 FA Cup defeat

Newcastle United player ratings from the 3-1 FA Cup fifth round defeat at home to Manchester City.

Newcastle United exited the FA Cup following a 3-1 defeat to Manchester City in the fifth round.

Eddie Howe made four changes from Wednesday’s 2-1 win over Manchester United. As a reward for his late winner, Will Osula led the line and Nick Woltemade returned from illness.

Joe Willock and Sven Botman also came into the starting line-up as Anthony Gordon, Joelinton and Dan Burn dropped to the bench, while Jacob Ramsey dropped out altogether due to suspension.

Harvey Barnes gave the Magpies the lead in the 18th minute when he was found by Sandro Tonali to race forward and coolly finish into the top corner past James Trafford.

The strike ended a run of 12 matches without a goal for Barnes, whose last came in the third round win over AFC Bournemouth.

Newcastle dominated the opening 25 minutes but faced relentless Man City pressure from then until half-time, as Savinho equalised in the 39th minute.

It was more of the same in the second half as Omar Marmoush put the visitors ahead when he got on the end of Matheus Nunes’ cross to the back post.

Marmoush then put the tie out of Newcastle’s reach with his second and Man City’s third in the 65th minute.

Here are our Newcastle United player ratings:

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice