Newcastle United players ratings: How each Magpies star performed in controversial Liverpool defeat

Jordan Cronin dishes out his Newcastle United player ratings from the 3-1 defeat to Liverpool.

Martin Dubravka - 7

placeholder image
Getty Images

Commanding performance from Dubravka, pulling out saves and claiming a number of crosses to relieve the pressure on his defensive teammates.

Newcastle United midfielder Jonjo Shelvey. placeholder image
Newcastle United midfielder Jonjo Shelvey. | Getty Images

Javier Manquillo - 7

placeholder image
Getty Images

Manquillo was at fault for two goals at Leicester but the Spaniard could barely be faulted at Anfield against his former club. 

Fabian Schar - 6

Had a slight injury issue during the week but should be okay to start on Sunday. Been in good form at the back under Howe.placeholder image
Had a slight injury issue during the week but should be okay to start on Sunday. Been in good form at the back under Howe.

Collided with Hayden, where Liverpool controversially levelled in the first-half. Would have conceded a penalty had Mo Salah not fired home the loose ball from his tackle on Sadio Mane.

Jamaal Lascelles - 7

placeholder image
Getty Images

Bounced back from his mistake at Leicester City. Absorbed plenty of Liverpool pressure to put in a more captain-liked performance. 

Jamal Lewis - 6

Has made the most of his opportunity since being brought in from the cold.placeholder image
Has made the most of his opportunity since being brought in from the cold.

Started brightly at Anfield but was forced to withdraw with a hamstring injury on 12 minutes.

Isaac Hayden - 7

Could return to the side to provide some much needed cover in front of the defence.placeholder image
Could return to the side to provide some much needed cover in front of the defence.

Handed his first start under Howe to offer defensive steel in the midfield. Was the player down with a head injury when Liverpool equalised.

Jonjo Shelvey - 5

Another former Liverpool player. Has scored twice against The Reds during his career but still looking to get off the mark for Newcastle this season.placeholder image
Another former Liverpool player. Has scored twice against The Reds during his career but still looking to get off the mark for Newcastle this season.

A performance to sum up the brilliance and not-so brilliance of Shelvey. Scored a seventh-minute screamer before gifting the ball to Mane in the build-up to Salah’s goal.

Ryan Fraser - 8

placeholder image
Getty Images

Was a real threat down the left-hand side. Provided the cross which led to Shelvey’s opener and was controversially denied a penalty under a challenge from Alexander-Arnold.

Jacob Murphy - 8

placeholder image

Put in a tireless display down the right-hand side. Supported Manquillo and offered a lot going forward. Aimed a left-footed shot narrowly wide in the second-half.

Allan Saint-Maximin - 7

placeholder image
Getty Images

Caused the Liverpool defence problems with his electric pace, which raises the question - is he best suited to play down the middle?

Joelinton - 7

placeholder image

Deployed in a deeper central midfield role, much like the position he played against Norwich City.

SUB: Matt Ritchie (on for Lewis, 12) - 7

For Lewis 15: Quickly settled into the game. 6placeholder image
For Lewis 15: Quickly settled into the game. 6

Steady display after replacing Lewis early on.

Callum Wilson (on for Saint-Maximin - 77) - 6

Was rested for the trip to Anfield. Played the final 10 minutes but not enough time to make an impact.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice