Eddie Howe deserves help - Newcastle United must act to rekindle Saudi ambition

Newcastle United can kill two birds with one stone by signing a top defender this month.

As Newcastle United aim to stun the might of Pep Guardiola, their most in-form defender is arguably a 19-year-old academy graduate who, until 27 days ago, had never played in a backline before. Kieran Trippier, Malick Thiaw, Sven Botman and Lewis Hall are the only options Eddie Howe has available - a bleak reality when aiming to topple a squad worth £1.1billion.

Supplemented by young midfielder Lewis Miley - a revelation since stepping in at right-back - the quintet will be trotted out again to take on Manchester City. Just 72 hours earlier, Newcastle went life and death with Bournemouth over 120 minutes and penalties to progress to the FA Cup fourth round.

Howe will not demand this publicly, but he must be given at least one defensive reinforcement this winter. Whether that be at right-back, with Trippier showing his age and Tino Livramento struggling to stay off the treatment table, or centre-back, to find a youthful operator akin to Thiaw or Botman, the Magpies cannot expect their manager to continue working miracles.

Year in, year out, Howe squeezes every drop of talent from his Toon battlers. Newcastle tend to perennially be swimming against the current financially yet keep pace with the Champions League contenders.

After an early winter wobble, four straight wins has the Magpies sitting sixth in the Premier League while fighting for both domestic cups. PIF should strike while the iron is hot to avoid the mini injury crisis from deteriorating into a catastrophe.

And no, this is not a knee-jerk reaction to the situation on the treatment table. Newcastle genuinely need to bolster their backline.

The average age of Newcastle’s nine defenders is 28.7. Take Lewis Hall and Livramento out of the equation and that figure rises to 30.7.

A fair argument could be made that PIF must to prove to the outside world that ambition remains paramount at St James’ Park. The Saudi-backed project took its most damaging blow in the summer when Alexander Isak left.

New CEO David Hopkinson insisted global domination is still the goal, but nothing would rekindle the romance more than a big-money signing this month. It could be the shot in the arm to convince the likes of Livramento and Sandro Tonali that Newcastle is the place to be.

Howe hinted at the hierarchy becoming more open to incomings due to the injury situation. He told reporters yesterday: “We need to know the full extent of injuries first, then make a decision around that. Regarding transfers, everybody is fully supportive. The problem for us is PSR. I don’t think there is any issue with anyone saying we can’t do this and we can’t do that.

“It’s more about what we can do, not what we can’t do. The key thing for us to consider is business now versus business in the summer. It’s value for money now vs value for money in the summer, and signing the right player. If you sign the wrong player now you are carrying that for a three, four or five year contract.

“Are the right players available in January? So, there is a lot to discuss and a lot to consider for our short-term needs and long-term decisions for the football club.”

The proof will be in the pudding, with Newcastle not making a January signing since Anthony Gordon’s arrival three years ago. In that deal, the Magpies proved the right player can be bought mid-season. There should be no reason why they cannot do the same again.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice