Premier League without VAR: Where Newcastle United, Liverpool, West Ham & Aston Villa sit
The PGMOL and Premier League have shared the referee and VAR audio from Liverpool defender Virgin Van Dijk’s red card against Newcastle United last month.
With the Reds trailing through Anthony Gordon’s 25th-minute opener, Van Dijk was dismissed shortly after following a last-man challenge on Alexander Isak. The Dutchman was raging with the decision and as a result is facing an extra game ban for his reaction.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdHis sending off, however, had little impact on Liverpool, who came from behind late on to win after substitute Darwin Nunez’s brace.
How the officials came to the Van Dijk decision was explained during Sky Sports’ “Match Officials: Mic’d Up”, hosted by Michael Owen and featuring Howard Webb.
VAR official Stuart Attwell began the conversation by saying: “APP (Attacking Possession Phase). Possible offside. Possible DOGSO (denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity).”
Referee John Brooks then replied “It’s outside [the box], outside, outside. And it’s a red card. He’s through and he’s gone through the man, red card.”
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdAfter checking the foul, VAR said: “Brooksy, it’s Stuart, I’m happy with the foul. I’m just going to check sanction and APP, standby. OK, so the ball’s going to roll across the front of him. Without the moving challenge, the attacker’s got position. He’s moving directly into the penalty area, that’s fine.”
Brooks can then be heard speaking directly to Van Dijk: “They will check [the decision]. And he’s not, he’s going inside. They will check, they will check. Just wait!
“I will tell you if you need to go and you need to go immediately. It’s clearly a foul, they have just checked the location. Don’t do anything silly. Listen you will be sent off, unless he [Isak] is offside. It is very, very tight.”
With no offside, VAR stood by Brooks’ decision, which he then told Van Dijk: “Free-kick. Go, go! Go now. Yes, no offside.”
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIndeed, Newcastle and Liverpool aren’t the only two clubs impacted by VAR this season.
Factoring in VAR decisions that led to goals being disallowed or awarded by the technology, including via penalties, here’s how the Premier League table might look as things stand:
1st: Man City
Estimated points without VAR: 12. Change: 0.
2nd: Tottenham
Estimated points without VAR: 12. Change: +2.
3rd: Liverpool
Estimated points without VAR: 10. Change: 0.
4th: West Ham
Estimated points without VAR: 10. Change: 0.
5th: Brighton
Estimated points without VAR: 9. Change: 0.
6th: Arsenal
Estimated points without VAR: 9. Change: -1.
7th: Crystal Palace
Estimated points without VAR: 7. Change: 0.
8th: Man United
Estimated points without VAR: 7. Change: 0.
9th: Nottingham Forest
Estimated points without VAR: 6. Change: 0.
10th: Aston Villa
Estimated points without VAR: 6. Change: 0.
11th: Brentford
Estimated points without VAR: 5. Change: -1.
12th: Chelsea
Estimated points without VAR: 4. Change: 0.
13th: Fulham
Estimated points without VAR: 4. Change: 0.
14th: Newcastle United
Estimated points without VAR: 3. Change: 0.
15th: Wolves
Estimated points without VAR: 3. Change: 0.
16th: Bournemouth
Estimated points without VAR: 2. Change: 0.
17th: Sheffield United
Estimated points without VAR: 1. Change: 0.
18th: Everton
Estimated points without VAR: 1. Change: 0.
19th: Luton Town
Estimated points without VAR: 0. Change: 0.
20th: Burnley
Estimated points without VAR: 0. Change: 0.
Comment Guidelines
National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.