placeholder image
Getty Images

Sandro Tonali in, 'unsung hero' out: The starting XI Newcastle United must use after transfer window

The summer transfer window closed on Friday night and Newcastle United are left to reflect on what ultimately proved to be a disappointing one.

The Magpies signed five players in total - although only four were new faces after Lewis Hall’s loan move from Chelsea was turned permanent.

Lloyd Kelly and John Ruddy arrived on a free transfers from AFC Bournemouth and Birmingham City, respectively, while Will Osula joined from Sheffield United and Odysseas Vlachodimos from Nottingham Forest as part of the PSR-forced deal that saw Elliot Anderson head to the City Ground.

Eddie Howe had identified the need to sign a centre-back and right forward this summer but in the end secured neither. Newcastle, for the best part of a month, chased a deal for Marc Guehi, only for negotiations to break down with Crystal Palace just over 24 hours before the deadline.

Frustration lingers on Tyneside, but all could be forgotten about if Howe’s side - bolstered by Sandro Tonali’s return - go on to have a successful first-half of the campaign.

For all the noise, United have started the campaign well, collecting seven points from a possible nine in the Premier League and advancing into the third round of the Carabao Cup. What is Howe’s strongest XI? Here’s what we think:

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice