‘Scary’ - Newcastle United face biggest selection dilemma of the season vs Wolves

Sandro Tonali is pushing for a Newcastle United start following two 90-minute showings for Italy

Does Eddie Howe back his trusted lieutenant, or does he take a risk? That is perhaps his biggest selection conundrum ahead of Newcastle United’s trip to the Midlands this weekend.

Sean Longstaff (left) and Newcastle United teammate Sandro Tonaliplaceholder image
Sean Longstaff (left) and Newcastle United teammate Sandro Tonali | Getty Images

Wolverhampton Wanderers are the opposition - with Molineux proving a bogey venue for the Magpies in recent years. Not since October 2011 have Newcastle earned a Premier League win away to Wolves.

Buoyed by an unbeaten start, the scout report sent to Howe following the recent international breaks would have been a joyful read. Alexander Isak bagged three goals for Sweden and Anthony Gordon was finally let off the England leash by Lee Carsley.

But Sandro Tonali’s heroics for Italy provided him with his first real dilemma of the campaign. The midfielder returned to the international fold following a 10-month lay-off and made an immediate impact - easing his nation’s woes two months on from a dismal Euro 2024 campaign.

Tonali gave them renewed hope, with a cheeky backheel assist setting up Federico Dimarco in Italy’s 3-1 comeback away win over France. He also bagged an offside goal against Israel, playing another 90 minutes to recharge his lung capacity following the lengthy break.

Coupled with a slick performance at Nottingham Forest and a 22-minute cameo versus Tottenham Hotspur must have Howe thinking: is Tonali ready?

His obvious competition for a starting berth is Sean Longstaff, one of Howe’s most faithful disciples. Despite the occasional murmurings from supporters, the North Shields native has seldom let Newcastle down and enjoyed his best goalscoring return last season.

He gives balance to the Toon engine room and Howe must decide whether to unsettle that dynamic on Sunday. Longstaff admitted in April that he battled through a foot injury once Newcastle signed the Italian knowing his place was up for grabs.

Both are now fit and available for selection as the Magpies aim for their first Premier League away win of the season. Speaking to BBC Radio Newcastle last month, Longstaff bigged up Tonali - the man coming for his jersey on Tyneside.

"He's such an important part of our team," he said. "When you can bring someone back into the fold of Sandro's quality and calmness...the presence he has around the group is massive. He adds to our strength and depth and places for competition.

"We have seen how hard he's worked at the very start of it all. It would have been easier for him to down tools and switch off from it all, but he went the opposite way. He looks so much better now than when he first came, which is scary to say.

"He's such a good person. He comes in every day and you can never really tell what he's thinking by looking at him, which is such a good thing but you could tell on Tuesday, especially, when we came in, the day before the game, he had a little smile on his face.

"You're just so happy for a friend really because what he went through was so hard and there were days you just wanted to give him a big cuddle and make sure everything was all right, but he's got a really good group around him away from football at the club and I'm just really happy to have him back."

Should Tonali start, the Wolves game could become a watershed moment in his Toon career. He is one stellar performance away from banishing the demons for good and establishing himself as a Premier League regular. 

Will that be on Sunday? Over to you, Mr Howe…

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice