'Significant' - Newcastle United takeover lawyer issues statement after Man City & Premier League verdict
Renowned sports lawyer Nick De Marco believes it is “significant” that parts of the Premier League’s Associated Party Transactions (APT) rules have been declared unlawful.
Manchester City launched legal action against the Premier League’s APT rules and on Monday claimed to have “succeeded with its claim”. In an official statement, Man City wrote “APT rules have been found to be unlawful” and that they “violate UK competition law and violate the requirements of procedural fairness.”
And in their most damning sentence, the Citizen wrote: “The Premier League was found to have abused its dominant position.”


The Premier League, meanwhile, said it “welcomes the Tribunal’s findings, which endorsed the overall objectives, framework and decision-making of the APT system”. The statement continued: “The Tribunal upheld the need for the APT system as a whole and rejected the majority of Manchester City’s challenges. Moreover, the Tribunal found that the Rules are necessary in order for the League’s financial controls to be effective.”
With both sides claiming a win, De Marco - the KC who previously acted for Newcastle United during their 2021 takeover and recently helped Leicester City avoid a points deduction for an alleged PSR breach, took to social media to explain.
“Today we have finally been able to read the written reasons in the MCFC v PL arbitration about the legality of the PL’s Associated Party Transaction Rules (‘APT’) and their application,” De Marco wrote.
“As is often the case with lawyers, both sides have declared victory. The truth is somewhere in between, with each side winning on different issues. The fact, however, that parts of the PL’s APT Rules have been declared unlawful is significant.
“Just a few days after the European Court found parts of FIFA’s RSTP were unlawful, and coming not long after the ESL case in Europe (finding FIFA and UEFA rules to be unlawful), and the decision of an FA Rule Arbitral Tribunal that The FIFA and FA’s cap on football agents fees was unlawful, the case represents another example of the increasing tendency of courts and tribunals to hold sports regulators to closer scrutiny than has previously been the case the – in particular where economic activity is involved and where issues of freedom of movement and competition law arise. In addition, some of MCFC’s ‘wins’ in the APT case were based on English public law principles of procedural fairness.
“I have been inundated with media requests to discuss the decision, which I must decline, and say no more than I do here for now. Many of the clients I advise will have various issues and interests that will arise from the decision, so it would be inappropriate for me to speak about it now, or express my own opinion.
“All that I can say is we are living in the most exciting time for sports law. I have never myself been one to celebrate the greater commercialisation and therefore legalisation of sport and its regulation, but it is a real fact of life and economic activity, such that this tendency for greater scrutiny of sports regulation is inevitable. It does perhaps also lend further support to the calls for greater independence, and transparency, in the regulation of sport.”
The Premier League is set to host an emergency meeting with all 20 of its club next week to discuss potential changes to APT rules. In the meantime, the Premier League say it “will continue to operate the existing APT system, taking into account the findings made by the Tribunal.”
Newcastle United are watching on with a keen eye. APT rules which were introduced in the wake of the Magpies’ £305million takeover by the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia three years ago, therefore restricting their ability to land lucrative deals with companies linked to PIF.
