'I suspect' - Newcastle United told chances of suing Premier League after Man City statement
Football finance expert Stefan Borson doesn't believe Newcastle United have a claim to make following the legal battle between Manchester City and the Premier League.
Man City claimed a victory in their legal challenge against the Premier League’s Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules and in an official statement wrote “APT rules have been found to be unlawful” and that they “violate UK competition law and violate the requirements of procedural fairness.”
APT rules were introduced in the wake of Newcastle’s £305million takeover by the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia three years ago, therefore immediately restricting their ability to land lucrative deals with companies linked to PIF. The front-of-shirt sponsorship with Sela, understood to be worth around £25million per-season, was subject to a ‘fair market value’ check.


It has left Newcastle supporters wondering how the arbitration ruling will impact their club, with one fan messaging talkSPORT to ask if there are grounds to sue the Premier League.
“It depends what they have to anchor it to,” former Crystal Palace owner Simon Jordan replied. “City had a couple of commercial deals to anchor it to.
“If Newcastle have an example of a commercial deal that has been pushed back by the Premier League because of an Associated Party Transaction that hasn’t been valued at that premise, then they might have a go too because the door has been opened.”
However, Borson is doubtful: “The one thing that is beyond doubt in terms of reading this decision is that these rules were brought in relation to the takeover of Newcastle. Within five days, the other clubs were writing to each other to say ‘we have to get some rules in place’.
“Although that wasn’t the ultimate finding of the tribunal, it is clear on the face of the facts.
“Behind the scenes, there are loads and loads of APT transactions that have been successfully processed by the Premier League so it gives an example as of June, where it says 52 APT have been successfully processed and were processed relatively quickly, and 11 took a bit longer.
“I would assume some of the rejections came in that subset 11 but the key point is, lots of transactions under these rules have been processed historically and therefore will continue to be.
“I suspect Newcastle will not have a claim for any particular transaction that has been turned down and to be perfectly honest with you, even City, despite some their successes in setting asides some of the rejections, don’t necessarily have a legal claim in respect to those sponsorship agreements.”
The Premier League is set to host an emergency meeting with all 20 of its clubs next week to discuss potential changes to APT rules. The Premier League say it “will continue to operate the existing APT system, taking into account the findings made by the Tribunal.”
